Turns out a loyalty program isn't a retention system


HighDef Studio

May 18th, 2026

Most dispensaries have a loyalty program. Very few have a retention system.

I had the pleasure of being on two cannabis marketing podcasts in the last month.

CannaBud Marketing's Dispensary Marketing Podcast with Brandon Quan, and MediaJel's Cannabis Marketing Live with Jake Litke.

A few things that stuck with me from both:

  • Over-messaging is the most consistent issue I see in audits. I told Jake about a retailer sending two emails a day to their entire list. The root of it is usually fear. Operators are afraid patrons will forget about them if they don’t message daily. The bigger problem is what happens after the opt-out. Nobody has a plan to get those people back.
  • Click-to-VISIT rate matters more than open rate. A 40% open rate means nothing if zero of those people walk in. It’s the metric I keep coming back to in audits.
  • The leak is almost never in the loyalty program itself. Stores have loyalty programs. Very few have a retention system. The welcome sequence usually doesn’t exist, and the first five visits aren’t being supported by anything.
  • Advertising to your regulars usually beats chasing new traffic. Jake’s data reports 20 to 40% more revenue from engaged regulars, 5 to 15% less churn. Dollar for dollar, a better return than chasing new customers.

Btw, here's the example retention journey I referenced on the Cannabud episode:

Both are worth a listen:

Stop Sending Every Dispensary Customer the Same Deal - Ep 55: HighDef Studio

video preview

How to Increase Repeat Customers at Your Dispensary (Retention Audit Guide)

video preview

Lmk what you think. Did i miss anything?

~ Steph

6825 S 7th St, #8634, , Phoenix, AZ 85042
Unsubscribe · Preferences

background

Subscribe to Studio Vault Monthly